top of page

How green is your analytical method? A short guide to GAPI and AGREE

Writer: Ahmet CETINKAYA
Ahmet CETINKAYA
17 hours ago
3 min read

Behind a single number on an analytical report there may be litres of organic solvent, hours of instrument time, several preparation steps and a bottle of hazardous waste. Green analytical chemistry asks a simple question: can we get the same reliable answer with less? Here is what makes a method "green", how chemists turn that idea into a score, and where small electrochemical sensors fit in.

What makes an analytical method "green"?

Green analytical chemistry focuses on making analytical procedures more environmentally benign and safer for people. Many criteria matter at once: the amount and toxicity of reagents, the waste generated, the energy needed, the number of steps, and whether the procedure is miniaturised or automated. These ideas are summarised in the 12 principles of green analytical chemistry, remembered with the mnemonic SIGNIFICANCE.

Greenness is therefore a multivariate property. A useful analogy is a nutrition label: no single number tells you whether a meal is healthy, but a standardised label shows at a glance where it does well and where it does not. Greenness metrics do the same for analytical methods.

From principles to a score

Most greenness assessments follow the same route:

  1. Describe the whole procedure: sample collection, transport and storage, sample preparation, reagents, instrument and final determination.

  2. Collect the inputs for each step, such as reagent volumes and hazards, waste and energy per sample, the number of steps, and where the measurement is made.

  3. Apply a metric tool, such as GAPI or AGREE, to convert these inputs into a pictogram or score.

  4. Compare alternatives and find the weakest step, the best place to start improving.

Two widely used tools: GAPI and AGREE

GAPI. The Green Analytical Procedure Index (2018) assesses the whole procedure, from sample collection and preparation to reagents, instrumentation and final determination. Each stage is coloured green, yellow or red according to its environmental impact, showing where a method's main burdens lie.

AGREE. The Analytical GREEnness metric (2020) takes its criteria from the 12 principles. Each criterion is transformed onto a common 0 to 1 scale, users can weight the criteria, and the final score appears in the centre of a clock-like pictogram; closer to 1 means greener. The software is free and open source.

Because metrics use different criteria, they do not always rank methods in the same order, so many studies report more than one. Scores are best read as a guide for comparison and improvement. Greenness never replaces validation: a method must first be accurate, precise and selective.

A drop of sample placed on a screen-printed electrode connected to a compact potentiostat in a bright, plant-filled laboratory
Green analytical chemistry at SAOnS Lab: a drop of sample, a disposable electrode and a compact instrument

Where electrochemical sensors fit in

Sensors built on disposable screen-printed electrodes address several green criteria at once. A measurement can be made in a drop of sample, often with little or no organic solvent, using compact low-power instruments, and the device can go to where the sample is. These features match what GAPI and AGREE reward: miniaturisation, less reagent and waste, lower energy demand and on-site analysis. Materials used to modify the electrode, such as nanomaterials or polymers, also have a footprint and belong in a complete assessment.

Key takeaways

  • Green analytical chemistry aims for methods that are safer for analysts and the environment without sacrificing analytical quality.

  • GAPI and AGREE turn many criteria into a pictogram that makes a method's strengths and weak points visible.

  • Miniaturised, on-site electrochemical sensors can reduce reagents, waste and energy, but still need full validation.

Green analytical chemistry at SAOnS Lab

At SAOnS Lab, we develop electrochemical sensors, including molecularly imprinted polymer and nanomaterial-based platforms, for drug and biomarker analysis, and green chemistry is one of our research interests. Our group has also published a review in TrAC Trends in Analytical Chemistry giving an overview of the current progress in green analytical chemistry by evaluating recent studies that used greenness assessment tools (Çetinkaya et al., 2023).

Are you assessing the greenness of your own methods, or looking for a partner in sustainable sensing? Get in touch with us through www.saonslab.com.

References

Płotka-Wasylka, J. (2018). A new tool for the evaluation of the analytical procedure: Green Analytical Procedure Index. Talanta, 181, 204–209. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.talanta.2018.01.013

Pena-Pereira, F., Wojnowski, W., & Tobiszewski, M. (2020). AGREE—Analytical GREEnness metric approach and software. Analytical Chemistry, 92(14), 10076–10082. https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.analchem.0c01887

Çetinkaya, A., Kaya, S. I., Özkan, S. A., et al. (2023). An overview of the current progress in green analytical chemistry by evaluating recent studies using greenness assessment tools. TrAC Trends in Analytical Chemistry, 168, 117330. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.trac.2023.117330

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
bottom of page